10 Best Picture Nominees?! Who Would've Made The Cut

Academy of Motion Picture Arts & Sciences President Sid Ganis announced this afternoon that the Oscar race for Best Picture—a race traditionally between five films, at least since World War II—will double the number of contenders starting with this year's presentation. "Having 10 best picture nominees is going [to] allow academy voters to recognize and include some of the fantastic movies that often show up in the other Oscar categories, but have been squeezed out of the race for the top prize," Ganis said.

It also makes room for more commercial picks, as recent Best Picture races have included few box-office hits and thereby hooked fewer viewers into the ceremony's broadcast. In 2008, 2007 and 2006, respectively, the five nominees for the top Oscar grossed a cumulative $70 million. Compare that to earlier this decade, when the five grossed upwards of $130 million. In doubling the field of contenders, you can fit movies like or that resonated both critically and commercially.

In the spirit of this new announcement, we're going to get all revisionist on cinema history. Who might've made the cut in the last five years, if ten films were nominated?

77th Academy Awards Best Picture Nominees:

• The Aviator
• Million Dollar Baby
• Sideways
• Finding Neverland
• Ray

Woulda-beens:

• Closer
  
• Hotel Rwanda
• Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind
• Maria Full of Grace
• Vera Drake

78th Academy Awards Best Picture Nominees:

• Crash
• Brokeback Mountain
• Munich
• Good Night, and Good Luck
• Capote

Woulda-beens:

• Walk the Line
  
• The Constant Gardner
• Cindarella Man
  
• A History of Violence
  
• Junebug

79th Academy Awards Best Picture Nominees:

• The Departed
• Little Miss Sunshine
• The Queen
• Babel
• Letters from Iwo Jima

Woulda-beens:

• Pan's Labyrinth
  
• Little Children
• Dreamgirls
• Borat
• Notes on a Scandal

80th Academy Awards Best Picture Nominees:

• No Country for Old Men
• Juno
• Atonement
• Michael Clayton
• There Will Be Blood

Woulda-beens:

• The Diving Bell and the Butterfly
• Lars and the Real Girl
• Into the Wild
• Away From Her
• Gone Baby Gone

81st Academy Awards Best Picture Nominees:

• Slumdog Millionaire
• Frost/Nixon
• The Curious Case of Benjamin Button
• The Reader
• Milk

Would-Beens:

• The Dark Knight
• Doubt
• Wall-E
• Revolutionary Road
  
• Rachel Getting Married